Melisa Fazio, P.A.-C.
Orthopedic Surgery
609 Quarter Street, Entrance A, Suite 1
Gladwin, MI 48624 Directions
4.8 out of 5
198 verified ratings
2 Locations
MyMichigan Orthopedics: Midland (Campus Ridge)
4401 Campus Ridge Drive, Suite 2200
Midland, MI 48640
198 Ratings, 118 Comments
The following ratings and reviews are based on verified feedback collected from independently administered patient experience surveys. The ratings and comments submitted by patients reflect their own views and opinions. Patient identities are withheld to ensure confidentiality and privacy.
AI Overview
Overall sentiment is strongly positive toward Melisa Fazio, P.A.-C. Patients consistently praise her compassion, clear explanations, strong clinical knowledge, and excellent bedside manner. Many recommend her and the office, citing successful hip and knee replacements and thorough pre- and post-op support. Staff and office coordination also receive frequent compliments. A few comments note minor room for office improvement (scheduling or phone access) but emphasize that outcomes and provider care make returning worthwhile.
Generated from the text of patient reviews
This AI summary is automatically generated from published patient reviews. It highlights common themes from the reviews, but as with all AI-generated content, there may be errors. Please exercise caution and refer to the original reviews for full context.
Jun 10, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
Received excellent care and attention from everyone involved with .y recent knee replacement surgery and reco very
Jun 3, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
Good staff, friendly, professional, and knowledgeable. Happy with the care I have had.
May 28, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
Friendly, thorough, attentive
May 28, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
She is very knowledgeable about medications and their side effects.
May 24, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
Yes would recommend
May 24, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
Professional I will say when I have an appointment and told arrive 15 minutes before scheduled time does not make sense. Had to wait a half hour to be seen. My time is important too.
May 23, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
Appointments were on schedule. Office visits were very organized, Diagnosis was explained thoroughly.
May 23, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
I love this surgeon and assistant, they are amazing and I felt like they really know me.
May 21, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
So far, so good. Can better evaluate after surgery.
May 21, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
Every person who works with me has been kind and professional
May 20, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
Melissa was very business like, just matter of fact, tick off the list and move on. I did not get a warm caring feeling type of personality. She did present as knowledgeable. I guess I just expected someone who would reassure me that everything with my knee replacement surgery would go well and that I was in good hands.
May 18, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
I received great care from Melisa. She is very caring and knowledgeable. She always answers all my questions.
May 10, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
I would definitely recommend
May 8, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
I'm not impressed by her, she treated me as if I should already know the answers to my questions as if I've had this major surgery done before, which I have not. Very business like, not encouraging, almost feel like I'm a waste of her time, didn't make me feel warm and welcomed. Rarely smiled .
May 1, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
This office is the best!! Melissa Fazio is awesome!
Apr 27, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
That they are all very nice and I would recommend them.
Apr 24, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
👍
Apr 20, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
Very professional and personal, I would highly recommend this provider.
Apr 17, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
She is knowledgeable and confident.. she is also a good listener consider your opinion seriously. she is easy to talk too..I’m happy with her and respect her professionalism.
Apr 17, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
She is very knowledgeable about medications and side effects. She caught the labs indicating stage 2 kidney failure and medication responsible. After stopping Naprosin, I was able to reverse my numbers to normal levels. She explains in a way you can easily understand and provides answers to questions.
Apr 16, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
Professional care from people who feel like family.
Apr 16, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
Very professional.
Apr 13, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
I've only been to see her one time. However, I have an upcoming surgery, so I'm sure I'll see her again. So far, no problems.
Apr 11, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
Excellent
Apr 11, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
Melisa is very kind and caring. She answered all my questions and made me feel confident in my upcoming surgery.
Apr 8, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
If need orthopedic doctors contact their office
Apr 8, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
Awsome people, kind and really care about you. Answer all questions that you have. Tell you what is going on and what to expect.
Apr 2, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
Highly recommend Dr Murphy and Melissa. The care and results I have received is excellent!! Up front and honest about my part in recovery.
Apr 1, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
Highly recommend
Mar 27, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
Very engaging and caring individual who conducted her pre-op information visit expertly and Thoroughly.
Mar 26, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
She is an excellent PA for Dr Murphy, I definitely will recommend them both and their office lady, check out (never got her name) is so helpful and caring! I have had great care with MyMichigan Orthopedics, I thank you for giving me my life back.
Mar 23, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
Very friendly and helpful
Mar 22, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
I love Melisa! She is dedicated to your needs. If you have an issue, she will go above and beyond to help you find a solution!!! She makes you feel like you're her only patient!!!
Mar 21, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
They listen to you and take the time to to talk to me no rushing
Mar 19, 2026
Very knowledgeable. Thoroughly researched my allergies to medication for best outcome for my surgery. A delightful and caring individual that answered all my questions and prepared me for my surgery. Highly recommend her.
Mar 19, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
Very efficient, caring and knowledgeable. Went above my expectations concerning my surgery.
Mar 16, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
Very efficient yet friendly and was treated with respect.
Mar 5, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
All good
Mar 4, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
Dr Murphy is amazing, so kind, patient, knowledgeable and understanding.
Feb 22, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
They were well informed about what I was going to go through.I felt like she listened to what I had to say. She was great. Anyone would feel comfortable talking to her.
Feb 21, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
I refer this office to everyone asking for a good orthopedic surgeon. I am very pleased with my new knee and the quality of work that was done. I am scheduled for my second one and I am excited to get it done so my quality of life is better.
Feb 19, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
Good person to see
Feb 19, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
Very personable caring and knowledgeable, I would definitely and highly recommend Melisa.
Feb 17, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
Explained the procedure clearly and answered my questions.
Feb 16, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
Very good very professional
Feb 16, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
We really like Melissa and Dr Murphy they explain everything where we can understand and make right decisions for us. Even in telling us how painful knee replacement is. They are very caring and answered all our concerns.
Feb 15, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
They are a knowledgeable and caring facility. I would recommend them.
Feb 12, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
Melissa and Dr. Murphy have been great through the whole preparation meeting up to my knee replacement. I had my left knee replaced a year ago and we’re gonna do my right one this time and they’ve done a wonderful job.
Feb 12, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
Recommend this provider for sure
Jan 30, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
Melissa has a great bedside manner and speaks to you about your health with great care and compassion.