Melanie A Shales

Family Medicine

1821 S Stoughton Rd

Madison, WI 53716 Directions

608-260-6000

www.ssmhealth.com

4.9 out of 5

140 verified ratings

140 Ratings, 70 Comments


The following ratings and reviews are based on verified feedback collected from independently administered patient experience surveys. The ratings and comments submitted by patients reflect their own views and opinions. Patient identities are withheld to ensure confidentiality and privacy.
Oct 1, 2025
I think she’s very confident and caring and I have nothing but good things to say about her

Sep 29, 2025
She did great. I don’t see any red flags.

Sep 28, 2025
Excellent and very caring provider. Also, quite knowledgeable.

Sep 24, 2025
She's a great provider! Highly recommend

Sep 20, 2025
Melanie always makes sure that you leave knowing that if your issue isn’t “fixed” that day that she will make sure you’re getting taken care of. She is very responsive and very knowledgeable.

Sep 20, 2025
She's great and listens!

Sep 18, 2025
Melanie is great! I am just beginning to know her and I am quite comfortable talking with her. She makes suggestions with respect for what my wishes are and doesn't "push" things if it's not what I'd like to do.

Sep 8, 2025
Melanie is a caring provider who is knowledgeable on current medical treatments. I’m very happy that she’s part of my care team.

Sep 8, 2025
She was easy to talk to, listened to what I said, explained things so I understood her.

Sep 5, 2025
I have enjoyed every interaction I have had with her. I feel well cared for and confident I'm getting good medical attention.

Aug 17, 2025
Great doctor! Will choose her every time.

Aug 14, 2025
Kind. Helpful. She kept me updated and got back to me as quickly as she could about what I should do next after knowing my condition. Communication was great.

Aug 10, 2025
Knowledgeable, personable, took my concerns, seriously. Educated me about night issue.

Aug 5, 2025
Very kind, takes her time- listens well.

Aug 2, 2025
She was great

Jul 23, 2025
Melanie was great she knew exactly what I needed and set it up immediately. She was kind and helpful and this was my first time seeing her. If I ever needed something again I would be sure to schedule an appointment with her specifically.

Jul 10, 2025
Melanie listened to my concerns and provided constructive advice. I was in a lot of stress and she took extra time to listen.

Jul 8, 2025
I appreciate Melanie’s bedside manner and quick response to my needs. Very pleased.

Jul 8, 2025
she was professional, knowlegeable and kind.

Jul 7, 2025
Very understanding.Good listener. Openminded.

Jun 27, 2025
She listens to my concerns! Always very nice to talk to

Jun 20, 2025
Amazing professional.

May 29, 2025
Good listening on her part. Did what was appropriate.

May 26, 2025
She was a good communicator, a good listener and seemed ro be honestly interested in me

May 25, 2025
She seems very educated about whether or not some of the vaccinations are covered by Medicare or medicaid health insursnce.

May 23, 2025
Listened well and affirmed my concerns, responded great to questions. Very kind demeanor.

May 21, 2025
She was very Good

May 5, 2025
Good listener.

Apr 28, 2025
She's very professional, intelligent, and caring

Apr 25, 2025
Melanie is amazing I have been seeing her a long time, she genuinely cares about her patients and wants to make sure all concerns are addressed before you leave, she is also great with follow up through MyChart

Apr 23, 2025
Better patient education and rationale to support advices. Don’t just be like “any of these are good options”. Actually explain why they are good options and give directions to thoughts process. Also go above what the care gap says the pt is missing. Like talk about cholesterol screening or other health benefits if pt hasn’t done one in over 5 years.

Apr 22, 2025
Very thorough and knowledgeable

Apr 21, 2025
Would love to see her again for medical needs

Apr 10, 2025
Melanie was fantastic! She listened to my concerns and took everything into consideration. She was kind and personable throughout the entire appointment.

Apr 10, 2025
Very good and right to the point.

Apr 10, 2025
I trust her completely. She is so friendly and knowledgeable.

Apr 9, 2025
She just a great job and makes you feel comfortable at my appointments. 5 🌟

Mar 31, 2025
She really cares about my concerns, is very respectful

Mar 13, 2025
She does an excellent job of keeping abreast of my health history and concerns. I feel like she actively listens and gives consideration to my questions and observations and as a result provides solutions that are able to be applied in a way that responds to the specifics of my situation.

Mar 5, 2025
To me she seems to take her job very seriously was very respectful nice and helpful I would recommend her to anyone from my experience.

Mar 4, 2025
Pleasant knowledgeable and tries hard to be helpful.

Feb 2, 2025
She is amazing. She always listens and answers my questions. She even asks questions I wouldn’t have thought about. She is just amazing.

Jan 24, 2025
I like her demeanor. She listens, answers questions. Treated me very well.

Jan 20, 2025
Melanie always listen to what my concerns are and she explains to me in a way that I understand. She is never rushing to get out the door. She takes her time and listens!!

Jan 17, 2025
A truly compassionate and caring person.

Jan 16, 2025
I had never seen her before this appointment. She was personable and professional.

Jan 13, 2025
AWESOM!!!! DEAN is extremely lucky to have her.

Jan 13, 2025
Was concerned and helpful as she could,

Jan 8, 2025
She listens and asks questions 😀

Dec 26, 2024
She was very caring and compassionate. She asked the right questions and genuinely cared about my health. I would definately schedule with here again.