Mathew Herbst, MD

Family Medicine

1300 S Century Ave

Waunakee, WI 53597 Directions

608-849-4315

www.getcare.ssmhealth.com

4.8 out of 5

183 verified ratings

183 Ratings, 77 Comments


The following ratings and reviews are based on verified feedback collected from independently administered patient experience surveys. The ratings and comments submitted by patients reflect their own views and opinions. Patient identities are withheld to ensure confidentiality and privacy.
Mar 9, 2026
The doctor listens carefully and clearly explains so that it is easy to understand for a teenager. Also checks whether the teen understands correctly.He takes all the time needed for care.

Mar 6, 2026
Very understanding doctor Very kind and listens to your problem

Mar 5, 2026
Dr. Herbst was knowledgeable and had an amazing bedside manner. He listened and took the time to carefully explain everything. He went out of his way to look at my medical history and make sure each point was addressed. He's an incredible physician.

Mar 4, 2026
Good

Mar 2, 2026
He is good at explaining what is needed

Feb 27, 2026
He listens to your health concerns and gives you very positive feedback and the care that is needed to get better

Feb 21, 2026
Proactive and engaged.

Feb 21, 2026
Compassionate and listens well!!

Feb 20, 2026
I feel comfortable having a conversation about any concerns and he gives well thought of feedback

Feb 18, 2026
A GREAT DOCTER AND A GREAT HUMAN BEING

Feb 10, 2026
He listens well, takes time with his patients, was very thorough, was helpful in referrals, did not push where I declined treatment options.

Feb 9, 2026
Dr Herbst provides me with excellent health care.

Feb 6, 2026
Thankful for his kindness.

Feb 2, 2026
When moving to a new area, we all know it is stressful, but I was nervous about starting over with a new Dr., but he is a very good one.

Jan 30, 2026
Dr. Herbst really took his time and listened to me. My concerns and questions were validated

Jan 28, 2026
It was a great visit. Mathew is personalable and knowledgeable.

Jan 24, 2026
First appointment with doctor. He acknowledged my ailment with concern and proceeded to make recommendations, followed by post appointment things to do.

Jan 19, 2026
Excellent Doctor.

Jan 19, 2026
I felt he listened to me and answered my questions in a way that i understood. He did not seem to hurry.

Jan 19, 2026
Listens ,responds appropriate, gives suggestions

Jan 13, 2026
Very thorough and knowledgeable. Knows how to make his patient feel comfortable

Dec 24, 2025
Very considerate person and doesn't push you aside because of age.

Dec 23, 2025
Everything you would expect in your primary physician.

Dec 20, 2025
Excellent.

Dec 19, 2025
Very impressed. Genuinely concerned, very thorough, thoughtful & considerate.

Dec 18, 2025
It was my first time seeing him and I was very impressed by his ability to treat me would definitely recommend him to my family and friends

Dec 17, 2025
Dr. Herbst is an outstanding physician and personable too! .

Dec 10, 2025
Very attentive and caring.

Dec 9, 2025
Nice and throughly checked me

Dec 6, 2025
I am very pleased with his care!!

Dec 4, 2025
Caring Doctor that takes the time to listen to you and does not rush you. Rare these days.

Dec 3, 2025
Very friendly and personable.Since it was my first time there, he ask me a lot of questions about my medical past and personal questions to know me better.

Nov 19, 2025
Always no nonsense, to the point and efficient.

Nov 4, 2025
I think Mathew Herbst is an excellent doctor. He seems to be very practical and also very knowledgeable. His care is great and I appreciate his opinions.

Nov 3, 2025
Just down to earth and explains things in layman terms

Nov 1, 2025
Very thorough and detailed exam, looked at all angles to ensure not missing anything

Oct 28, 2025
He was very kind and i felt like he really cared about my health. I didn't feel rushed.

Oct 27, 2025
He is a great Doctor

Oct 22, 2025
Lucky to have him, the right provider for me at this time.

Oct 22, 2025
He’s a great doctor

Oct 21, 2025
He is a good listener and answered my questions in a way that I could understand.

Oct 16, 2025
He's a good doctor, he listens to what say about my health and try to solve the problem

Oct 9, 2025
He is respectful, compassionate, and concerned for my overall health. I have a lot of respect for him because he chose family medicine, It is a challenging field and doesn't always get the respect it deserves.

Oct 8, 2025
Very caring and compassionate !!

Oct 1, 2025
He didnt rush going through the appointment and feel I m in good hands

Sep 30, 2025
Dr. Herbst answered my questions and as always had recommendations going forward.

Sep 26, 2025
Excellent listener, not rushed, very receptive to my concerns and questions,

Sep 9, 2025
Very knowledgeable

Aug 26, 2025
Overall very satisfying!

Aug 1, 2025
kind,patient,gave good suggestions