James Mathers, MD

Family Medicine

1700 Tuttle St

Baraboo, WI 53913 Directions

608-355-3800

https://www.getcare.ssmhealth.com/find-a-doctor/doctor-details/ james-d-mathers-md

4.9 out of 5

42 verified ratings

42 Ratings, 20 Comments


The following ratings and reviews are based on verified feedback collected from independently administered patient experience surveys. The ratings and comments submitted by patients reflect their own views and opinions. Patient identities are withheld to ensure confidentiality and privacy.
May 21, 2026
Very pleased with the experience

May 20, 2026
All went very well.

May 19, 2026
Dr. James Mathers is very knowledgeable, empathetic, and understanding...everything you could ask for in a medical professional. He took the time to explain things to me and listened to my concerns. 5 Stars!!!

Apr 21, 2026
Explained everything and was extremely helpful.

Apr 13, 2026
I have had Dr Mathers as my primary doctor for 34 years and have no complaint whatsoever about him in all these years…just not impressed with his current assistant who seems to have much to learn.

Apr 7, 2026
Excellent doctor. Wish he was there all the time.

Mar 10, 2026
Excellent. Answered my questions promptly on my chart and went over all my test results so understood them.

Feb 3, 2026
This man should have never retired. But I am so glad he fills in and I am able to be under his care.

Feb 1, 2026
Good doctor and always pleasant.

Jan 24, 2026
Very thorough and compassionate

Jan 20, 2026
He took time with me. I did not feel rushed. Both he and his assistant were very friendly and caring.

Dec 2, 2025
Dr Mathers is very personal and professional giving me the care I felt I needed.

Nov 23, 2025
Excellent experience felt very comfortable and well cared for! Thank you!!! Wish there could be more Dr Mathers around!

Nov 17, 2025
Only met once I liked him.

Nov 12, 2025
Wish I could have him as my primary care physician

Oct 24, 2025
His experience is a great asset

Sep 17, 2025
A very caring and knowledgeable physician.

Aug 26, 2025
Very knowledgeable in our situation.

Aug 12, 2025
He was very thorough and explained everything in laymen's terms and did not rush through the appointment

Aug 4, 2025
He really wants to help by giving good suggestions to improve my quality of life