Garrett A Mcnulty, MD

The following ratings and reviews are based on verified feedback collected from independently administered patient experience surveys. The ratings and comments submitted by patients reflect their own views and opinions. Patient identities are withheld to ensure confidentiality and privacy.

Apr 1, 2025

Dr. Mcnulty is very personable and professional. He was responsive to my questions and concerns and provided quick and decisive care.

Mar 29, 2025

Perfection every time and consistent!

Mar 25, 2025

I would definitely recommend him. It was a very comfortable appointment, he explained things well and presented options.

Mar 22, 2025

I left thinking that was one of the best interactions I had with a Dr. in along time and I like my assigned dr a lot so that means something.

Mar 21, 2025

He obviously listened well to my concerns, understood the problems, reassured me where appropriate and made clear areas that I should follow up.

Mar 8, 2025

Dr. McNulty was thorough. I received excellent care.

Feb 28, 2025

Very impressed with Dr Mcnultys overall approach to my situation

Feb 26, 2025

He has very good doctor-patient communication skills.

Feb 25, 2025

very friendly and approachable

Feb 20, 2025

He seems to have a depth of experience and was interested in helping me find help for my injury and offered the opportunity for follow up if needed.

Feb 12, 2025

He is a delightful, caring physician. I look forward to seeing him again in the future.

Feb 11, 2025

Very personable and nice.

Feb 11, 2025

seems to be a thoughtful provider

Feb 4, 2025

Highly recommend!

Jan 14, 2025

I wish Dr McNulty worked in Edgerton all the time- full time basis- he is an exceptionally super MD-

Jan 10, 2025

Even at young as he is, he had a genuine concern for me, having never seen me before. He took a fair amount of time to make me feel comfortable and then explained clearly what he felt was causing my coughing. He also took the time to explain the medications he prescribed and how they would relieve the cough. He was very approachable and very nice.

Jan 2, 2025

Was a pleasure to meet him and appreciate his expertise in quality health care!

Dec 31, 2024

Great Doctor

Dec 16, 2024

Dr. McNulty is a caring doctor who listens well. I highly recommend him.

Dec 16, 2024

Dr was very thorough and listened . Gave good advice.

Nov 24, 2024

Seemed very knowledgeable about the situation and was looking for answers about the situation where he seemed there might be a chance that there might be more to the problems I had than just the initial problem looking beyond and seem like he really cared

Nov 19, 2024

If possible I would have him as my Primary care provider.

Nov 13, 2024

Very professional and interested in my health.

Nov 9, 2024

Extremely nice

Nov 9, 2024

Garrett was fantastic!!

Nov 8, 2024

He was so pleasant @ Caring 👏

Nov 8, 2024

I was very impressed with him

Nov 1, 2024

Great Dr!!

Oct 30, 2024

Excellent provider!

Oct 29, 2024

a pleasure to meet. very happy with the care provided.

Oct 29, 2024

I feel like an equal partner in my health and preventative care.

Oct 26, 2024

Thank you for being so friendly and understanding with the challenging times I’m experiencing.

Oct 26, 2024

Dr. McNulty was very kind. I didn't feel rushed with him. He put me at ease.

Oct 25, 2024

He was very responsive to my concerns and needs

Oct 13, 2024

Wonderful and caring doctor

Oct 9, 2024

I was very impressed at how well he listened and how he gave me feedback to make sure he was understanding correctly what I was communicating. I felt he was really investing himself in the time he shared with me.

Oct 4, 2024

He is exceptional in his care and bedside manner. So blessed to have him on my team!

Sep 29, 2024

See previous notes. Dr. McNulty is a remarkable physician and a terrific human being. When being treated by him the experience lives up to the caring healthcare aspirations that SSM seems to want to fulfill.

Sep 26, 2024

Very thorough and spent adequate time with me

Sep 24, 2024

My experience with him was just above and beyond. Although it was just a quick pre-op I very much felt listened to and walked through everything even my upcoming procedure.

Sep 18, 2024

I’m a little sad I can’t select Dr. McNulty as my primary doctor, he was excellent!

Sep 18, 2024

Very nice and caring

Aug 27, 2024

Taking good explanation to patient and so kind thanks

Aug 26, 2024

I think you have a really fine doctor here and you need to do whatever it takes to keep him more of his colleagues need to be like him

Jul 29, 2024

It is a shame we are losing such a talent- seems every time i turn around i need to look for yet another dr.as the current one is leaving- BUT then you already know this.

Jul 27, 2024

Always fantastic. Sad SSM can't keep any primary care docs or in general in our region.

Jul 25, 2024

He's AWESOME!!! He takes the time to really listen to you and dig into your concerns with you.

Jul 13, 2024

Doctor Mcnulty is the best doctor ever!! He is the ONLY reason I use SSM.

Jul 9, 2024

He very good. I hope you will keep him.

Jul 3, 2024

He is the most caring and thorough doctor I have ever had the pleasure to see. I have seen many doctors in my 69 years.