Garrett A Mcnulty, MD

The following ratings and reviews are based on verified feedback collected from independently administered patient experience surveys. The ratings and comments submitted by patients reflect their own views and opinions. Patient identities are withheld to ensure confidentiality and privacy.

Oct 15, 2026

I would highly recommend Dr. Mcnulty.

Oct 14, 2026

Appreciate him listening and understanding my situation and making informed recommendations and helping to resolve the issue I was having.

Oct 14, 2026

Offered advice to help relieve some of the pain I’ve been experiencing

Oct 14, 2026

This doctor was a breath of fresh air. He made me feel comfortable immediately, listened attentively, and addressed everything I thought was important. His treatment plan was explained in a way I could understand, and his bedside manner was very warm and professional. I haven’t had a doctor like him in years, and I will try to schedule him as my doctor as much as possible even though he is a “floater” and visits multiple clinics.

Oct 11, 2026

very good at his job

Oct 9, 2026

Best PCP type visit ever. I wish he was full time just here

Oct 3, 2026

I found Dr. McNulty well balanced with his professionalism as well as being personable. He was extremely attentive to my health concerns giving me some excellent insight and advice.

Oct 2, 2026

He genuinely cares and takes necessary steps to assist and explain everything that is easily understood.

Sep 30, 2026

great guy explained things so i could understand

Sep 30, 2026

Very thorough and connected with me not just medically but I felt like a person and not just like another to do item on his list. I didn’t feel stupid for coming to the doctor. I haven’t had a lot of positive experiences with medical professionals in the past from another state and I’m very pleased by this first visit.

Sep 29, 2026

A caring MD and listening man.

Sep 16, 2026

When I left the clinic I felt like he really spent quality time with me addressing my concerns.

Sep 16, 2026

Very thorough even though he was behind schedule

Sep 12, 2026

He was the most caring and thorough doctor I have ever met. He went above and beyond to help me find a solution to my problem. I was not rushed and did not feel like I was just another patient in his day. He made me feel like myself and that I mattered!

Sep 11, 2026

What an excellent provider. You work want him as your doctor!

Sep 5, 2026

He is an asset to your organization

Sep 5, 2026

He’s obviously a caring provider who is interested in making sure his patients are provided the best care.

Sep 2, 2026

Dr. McNulty was amazing. One of the most caring doctors I have ever met. He is a wonderful doctor. Took his time and explained everything. I sure wish he would be in Jvl clinic and not traveling. Best doctor!!!

Aug 28, 2026

Mr. McNulty was exceptionally pleasant to collaborate with; he demonstrated great professionalism and dedication to his work.

Aug 27, 2026

Great doctor

Aug 26, 2026

I was a little worried going in and coming out I was somewhat relieved.

Aug 19, 2026

frendly and caring to a persons needs . as part of your health care

Aug 12, 2026

He is one of the best. You are fortunate to have him on staff.

Aug 8, 2026

Dr. McNulty is fabulous. I wish he were permanent. I follow him from place to place for my care.

Aug 4, 2026

Dr. McNulty's nurse (Terry?) also was very caring.

Jul 30, 2026

very good experience I feel very comfortable with him talking about my care.

Jul 28, 2026

Gracias doctor por su amable atención para esta familia, se lo agradecemos mucho, dios lo bendiga siempre. (English translation: Thank you doctor for your kind care for our family. We thank you very much. God bless you always.)

Jul 25, 2026

Dr. Mcnulty was wonderful, patient and we appreciate his help!

Jul 22, 2026

He is outstanding.

Jul 19, 2026

Knowledgeable and gives great advice

Jul 17, 2026

Best doctor I've seen in a very long time. Compassionate, caring and a joy to talk to.

Jul 16, 2026

Very nice guy very professional. Have I ever had to see somebody again I just like to see him. I wish I could have him as a primary doctor.

Jul 14, 2026

Thanks Dr. McNulty - I appreciate you.

Jul 10, 2026

Dr Mcnulty was very personable and not only explained certain issues and causes, but also underlying areas of concern.

Jun 22, 2026

This was the 2nd time I had opportunity to have an appointment with Dr Mcnulty. He was very kind, professional and involved with my questions and concerns. If it were possible, I would very much enjoy having him as my permanent provider.

Jun 12, 2026

Thank you for what you do, Dr. Mcnulty! We are very lucky to have you as a float. I tend to prefer to be able to keep having my family seen in Evansville, as it is more convenient. Thank you for including my child in the decision-making process when it came to the type of medication to use and for providing more information to her about how to take it. Thank you for also showing me that I can message you as one of her providers now, as well as how to do that! We appreciated your friendliness and kindness! You are an asset to SSM!!!

Jun 11, 2026

It was first time I met him. Knew all about my problems. Listened to me and explained things. I wish he could be my primary Dr. I definitely would continue seeing him.

Jun 4, 2026

Thank you Dr. Mcnulty for taking the time to cover my list and to take so seriously my concerns. Thank you for explaining each new medication and answering my questions about them.

Jun 2, 2026

He was a fine physician

May 30, 2026

He has a bright, upbeat and caring disposition.

May 27, 2026

He is a great Doctor!

May 13, 2026

I thought he was very thoughtful, respectful and trying to do the right thing for me. I was a tiny bit worried about his suggested change in medications. I guess that's a doctor's job, but it makes me wonder why my usual doctor didn't recommend this.

May 6, 2026

Doctor was very calming, interested in my care, while makung recommedations for future care.

Apr 18, 2026

He was extremely kind, responsive, and respectful.

Apr 18, 2026

Very knowledgeable and explained everything I needed to know in great detail / excellent doctor

Apr 14, 2026

Very attentive to my issue. Very friendly,I would like to have him as my Primary

Apr 10, 2026

I liked the way he explained any new technology that is out there for me for the future personally I really hope that he’s available for my next appointment.

Mar 23, 2026

I don’t know much about him. It he treated me very well. I appreciate his good care!

Mar 18, 2026

Dr,McNulty is absolute fantastic. He listens, is engaging, explains things well and is most willing to say aloud his thinking, which I greatly appreciate. He is NOT.."do this because i said so."

Mar 14, 2026

Great doctor. Very personable. Explanations very clear and gave me time to explain my injury. I very highly recommend him.