Allie Eickholtz, M.D.
5.0 out of 5
77 verified ratings
77 Ratings, 51 Comments
The following ratings and reviews are based on verified feedback collected from independently administered patient experience surveys. The ratings and comments submitted by patients reflect their own views and opinions. Patient identities are withheld to ensure confidentiality and privacy.
AI Overview
Patients consistently praise Dr. Eickholtz for professionalism, clear explanations, and compassionate, attentive care. Many highlight surgical competence and effective pre-op discussions about risks and benefits. Staff and clinic efficiency, friendliness, and teamwork are frequently noted. A few comments mention difficulty reaching her via the patient portal. Overall sentiment is highly positive, with multiple strong recommendations and satisfied patients after procedures.
Generated from the text of patient reviews
This AI summary is automatically generated from published patient reviews. It highlights common themes from the reviews, but as with all AI-generated content, there may be errors. Please exercise caution and refer to the original reviews for full context.
May 11, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
Friendly and informative
May 7, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
First doctor that listened to me and done something about it!
May 6, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
She is very thorough and gives you plenty of time to answer questions. She made me feel very comfortable.
Apr 28, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
Very freindly surgeon.
Apr 9, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
Best you will ever have
Apr 8, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
Excellent!! Great communication and even better plan for next steps :)
Apr 1, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
Very good would recommend as a surgeon to anyone
Mar 27, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
More than satisfied with my visit, she is very knowledgeable. Answered my questions. I would recommend her to anyone.
Mar 27, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
Good job
Mar 23, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
Very nice provider and staff
Mar 20, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
I would highly recommend them
Mar 16, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
Super nice, answered all my questions. Incisions healed great,can hardly see them!
Mar 13, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
I was very impressed and comfortable.
Mar 12, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
Dr. Eickholtz saved my life and I would highly recommend her. Her care and compassion go above and beyond. She is truly an amazing surgeon and a wonderful human.
Mar 9, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
She is a very good dr and so caring she's the best.
Mar 7, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
I would tell them that she is someone you can but your medical worries a side she tells you what is needed for your medical situation and very well informed on what is needed.
Mar 2, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
Very nice, friendly helpful, genuinely interested in helping
Mar 1, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
Very kind, listened and was proactive in taking next steps to furthering better health. I give her total thumbs up!
Feb 23, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
Made an uncomfortable situation manageable and helped me with a plan moving forward.
Feb 20, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
Allie is very nice, caring and a very good surgeon. I have always had a good experience when being around her or her staff.
Feb 18, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
I think it was one of the very best doctors appointments I have had in a long long time I feel like she took her time. She explained things and I was really impressed and I’m [AGE] years old so it takes a lot to impress me.
Feb 16, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
Professional and courteous
Feb 16, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
Great so far. I would highly recommend
Feb 13, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
Very good doctor explain the pros and cons of the surgery. Now it's just up to me to make up my mind whether I want to get that done.
Feb 10, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
Allie Eichholtz is an incredibly competent surgeon. I have the utmost respect for her and her staff.
Feb 5, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
Very pleasant to talk too. Listened to my concerns and she was very informative.
Feb 1, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
Courteous, caring and efficient.
Jan 30, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
Was satisfied with the procedure
Jan 29, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
Dr Allie and staff are efficient, courteous and professional. Dr. Allie performed a colonoscopy, colectomy and just recently removed a large hemorrhoid. From our first meeting at the colonoscopy, follow up appointment, colectomy and further follow-up appointments both my husband and I are so impressed with her care and answering all of our questions. I have recommended her, office staff already to others. I would also like to say Thank You to her entire staff for their understanding and care.
Jan 22, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
Wonderful care team
Jan 22, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
Our first visit was per our primary physician and the visit was to meet the physician that would perform the colonoscopy. Prior to this there was no encounter with the office or physician. However would not hesitate in turning to them in time of need. Everyone was top notch professionals.
Jan 22, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
Very proffesional staff from first phone call to follow up, Dr Allie listens to my issues and helps me understand what will happen!
Jan 9, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
Very professional. An I would recommend
Jan 3, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
Excellent, professional, and friendly
Dec 31, 2025
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
Easy to talk to and had answers to all my questions. Made me feel comfortable.
Dec 25, 2025
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
Amazing friendly caring clean respectful and top nitch
Dec 15, 2025
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
I received very good care and would highly recommend this facility.
Dec 12, 2025
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
Everything went smoothly, and I really really liked the doctor her care her concern and her patience
Dec 9, 2025
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
Yes this office runs quite efficiently and with care and concern ... overall besides the office..mI'd highly recommend this Dr!!!...she was top-notch !! In EVERY ASPECT...don't get rid of her! Thx for acknowledging and have a beautiful day
Dec 3, 2025
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
Yes, I already have. She is a wonderful surgeon, doctor kind professional I couldn’t ask for anybody better than Dr. Eickholtz!
Nov 28, 2025
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
Could not be more pleased with the treatment and support I received from Dr Eickholtz and the staff at MyMichigan Hospital West Branch.
Nov 19, 2025
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
Very friendly staff
Nov 14, 2025
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
Dr Allie explained my forth coming surgery in detail. Staff was so friendly and I highly recommend Dr Allie Eickholtz and staff!
Nov 11, 2025
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
very good
Nov 9, 2025
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
She is engaged and "present" in the room during the appt while listening and asking questions about current complaints.
Oct 30, 2025
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
She explained everything to me very well. The only problem i have is I can't reach her through My Chart. I have a few more questions I want to ask, I will call the office tomorrow. I am assuming I will get my questions answered quickly.
Oct 27, 2025
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
She is very kind and listens to your concerns and does what ever needed to make things good for you
Oct 27, 2025
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
Great job professional
Oct 23, 2025
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
Great Doctors and Staff and would recommend
Oct 18, 2025
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
Awesome