Thomas W. Shin, MD
General Surgery
Hamilton Surgical Associates
355 Westfield Rd, Ste 120A
Noblesville, IN 46060 Directions
5.0 out of 5
101 verified ratings
101 Ratings, 52 Comments
The following ratings and reviews are based on verified feedback collected from independently administered patient experience surveys. The ratings and comments submitted by patients reflect their own views and opinions. Patient identities are withheld to ensure confidentiality and privacy.
AI Overview
Dr. Shin is consistently praised for clinical excellence, clear communication, and compassionate care. Patients frequently note thorough explanations of diagnoses and surgical plans, attentive pre/post-op support, and strong follow-up. Staff and nurses are described as friendly and efficient, contributing to positive overall experiences. Several comments highlight successful hernia surgery and life-saving intervention. Overall sentiment is highly positive with emphasis on trust, competence, and good outcomes.
Generated from the text of patient reviews
This AI summary is automatically generated from published patient reviews. It highlights common themes from the reviews, but as with all AI-generated content, there may be errors. Please exercise caution and refer to the original reviews for full context.
Aug 21, 2026
Very professional and kind staff!
Aug 20, 2026
Dr shin is awesome. He tells it like it is and speaks so I can understand what he is talking about. Doesn’t use big medical terms
Aug 19, 2026
Thanks for taking care of me!
Aug 3, 2026
Dr Shin and the office staff are very friendly
Jul 31, 2026
Very realistic and doesn’t sugar coat. When morbidly obese people like myself need a wake up call and someone who is a straight shooter
Jul 31, 2026
I would like to thank Dr. Shin and staff for everything you did in my time of need. What a great staff and surgeon.
Jul 7, 2026
The staff from the emergency room to the surgical team were all very compassionate and understanding!
Jun 25, 2026
I love Dr. Shin and his team. You are all amazing!
Jun 25, 2026
On, very polite, nice and professional. Listen well and explained in detail what needed to be done.
May 21, 2026
Staff and doctor are always extremely nice and welcoming. I always get right in and out and leave with no questions as they all get answered in the office. So thankful for dr. Shin and staff.
May 20, 2026
Very professional , caring and thorough. Dr Shin is very attentive to detail
May 8, 2026
Dr. Shin was very good in analyzing my symptoms and had multiple options for care.
May 6, 2026
I was very impressed with the entire staff. And the Doctor
Apr 24, 2026
Distance is my biggest concern but the care and respect was top notch
Apr 22, 2026
Dr. Shin and his team have been incredible!
Apr 22, 2026
Very kind, informative, helpful, encouraging, and organized staff. I truly appreciate them all.
Apr 21, 2026
Dr Shin and staff were friendly and professional.
Apr 20, 2026
My surgeon was very good, he did an analysis of my symptoms and gave me great advice
Apr 20, 2026
Dr. Shin is a very compassionate understanding human! God Blees Thank you!
Mar 20, 2026
I felt like I was truly being taken care of to the best of the ability of the team. They were all so nice and knowledgeable and careful and treated me with so much kindness and respect I had so much confidence that they were doing what needed to be done.
Mar 18, 2026
Dr. Shin is very thorough and considerate.
Very pleased with the outcome of my surgery and post-op care.
Mar 16, 2026
Dr. Shin was great! He answered all my questions, listened to my concerns and made me feel comfortable. He explained everything in detail. Took great care with myself and waiting companion.
Mar 16, 2026
I loved Dr. Shin! He answered all my questions, took time to explain things and I felt comfortable with him.
Mar 16, 2026
Excellent and caring staff.
Mar 16, 2026
Doctor and staff were very nice and professional.
Feb 20, 2026
Everyone was very professional.
Jan 29, 2026
Dr. Shin listened to my concerns. My recovery has been remarkable. Scheduling appointments was easy. I am please with the follow through.
Jan 22, 2026
Dr. Shin was courteous, caring and knowledgable. He took time to explain the surgery, answering all my questions.
Jan 16, 2026
I feel that my care has been exemplary, with respect for my questions and concerns.
Jan 7, 2026
All staff was friendly and responsive.
Jan 7, 2026
Everyone at the office is incredibly kind and professional. Dr. Shin takes the time to explain everything, and listens to my questions and comments.
Jan 1, 2026
Dr Shin is an amazing doctor.
Jan 1, 2026
Dr.shin was awesome answering all my questions and going to fix my stomach issues and the staff there are awesome
Jan 1, 2026
For over a year I had been dealing with issues that I felt were gall bladder related. I had been through several tests and finally asked if I could have my gall bladder removed. I made an appointment with Dr. Shin’s office. His nurse Lindsay was so kind and compassionate. Dr Shin listened to me. I felt like he understood me and wanted to help me feel better. I trusted him to take care of me. The day of surgery went so smoothly. The anesthesiologist was awesome! I told him about the issue I had at my last surgery with nausea. I woke up feeling GREAT! Everyone on the surgical staff was amazing. They were all so kind in taking care of me. They were awesome! They made sure I was comfortable at all times. I am so pleased with my entire experience. Dr Shin and the entire staff gave me my life back! I can’t thank them enough.
Dec 19, 2025
Great staff. And a very kind and knowledgeable doctor.
Dec 11, 2025
I have been nothing but impressed with Dr Shin. He is professional and gets down to business but is also a good listener and good at making sure I understand what’s going on. I would absolutely recommend him. Also the office staff are extremely friendly and easy to communicate with.
Dec 3, 2025
Dr. Shin and his staff have been amazing.
Nov 25, 2025
Dr Shin is amazing. He took the time to explain my condition and the surgery required to repair it. He left no question unanswered.
Nov 25, 2025
Great staff and Dr Shin is amazing!!
Nov 25, 2025
I felt welcome and had a good conversation with the nurse and the doctor discussed the surgery and my concerns.
Nov 14, 2025
Dr Thomas Shin - great results from my recent hernia surgery. Post op care was high level as well! [PHI redacted]
Nov 13, 2025
Great group of people
Nov 10, 2025
He it very courteous and a great person
Nov 6, 2025
Dr Shin was amazing and is one of the best Dr’s!!
Oct 31, 2025
Nurse Lindsey & Dr. Shin were very efficient and accommodating. Both answered all questions regarding pre & post-op. Left appt with good feeling about my surgical team.
Oct 24, 2025
I apprecited the time Dr. Shin took to explain all steps of the procedure and followup. He made sure I understood all issues.
Oct 24, 2025
Dr Shin saved my life! He operated on me when no one else would. And I feel like I now have a great start on my road to recovery. Thank you Dr Shin!
Oct 16, 2025
Could not have had a better crew!
Oct 10, 2025
Dr Shin is a wonderful, caring surgeon! The whole staff has been great
Oct 9, 2025
Dr Shin truly cares about helping his patience. He is an awesome surgeon and answered my questions without hesitation. More importantly he truly wants the patient to have quality of life and relieve pain and suffering.