Peter K. Sculco, MD

Orthopedic Surgery

HSS - The Pavilion

541 East 71st Street, 6th Floor

New York, NY 10021 Directions

(212) 606-1771

www.hss.edu

4.9 out of 5

2,039 verified ratings

2,039 Ratings, 144 Comments


The following ratings and reviews are based on verified feedback collected from independently administered patient experience surveys. The ratings and comments submitted by patients reflect their own views and opinions. Patient identities are withheld to ensure confidentiality and privacy.
Oct 8, 2026
Extremely good doctor explains everything in clear concise manner. Very empathetic

Oct 8, 2026
HSS hospital never disappoints

Oct 6, 2026
From scheduling the appointment , to meeting the doctors assistant, and then the doctor himself , everyone at every desk we stopped at from the moment we walked in was out standing, caring, friendly. The doctor listened, presented options, and informed us of everything will be taken care of from beginning to end. There’s a reason we drove two hours away from where we live for this appointment and your care team, your Hospital, your staff, even the security guards were courteous and helpful. AND MOST IMPORTANT, EVERYONE WE MET WERE SMILING.

Oct 1, 2026
Dr. Sculco is absolutely fantastic, clearly dedicated to and on the cutting edge of his profession, friendly, funny, and a pleasure to meet. He created an exceptional comfort level.

Sep 24, 2026
Dr. Peter Sculco and his staff were great! Respectful, thoughtful explanations, and I feel I will be in good hands when I am ready to have my surgery.

Sep 22, 2026
Great experience all the way around!!!

Sep 22, 2026
Dr. Sculco was professional and explained everything in detail to patient. I am very impressed with the services received by the entire staff.

Sep 18, 2026
Because of Dr Peter Sculco’s professional skills I have regained my quality of life

Sep 18, 2026
It was good experience at HSS. I was greeted by Gabriella, who was very pleasant. Then I saw Dr. Sculco and Joy who were great.

Sep 18, 2026
They were all very good , especially births girls by the same name Christina’s. They were there to provide me more understanding

Sep 18, 2026
Dr Sculco was very attentive. Explained possible treatment in details put me at easy

Sep 17, 2026
I’ve been a patient at HSS & talk to Peter Sculco since 2017. There are no words to describe the exemplary treatment I have received by every single employee HSS. Dr. Sculco has performed 5 surgery is on me. His kindness, brilliant and comprehensive surgical skills along with his follow up and understanding is beyond the epitome of the true nature of of an exceptional, and unique physician, and sergeant

Sep 17, 2026
Brilliant surgeon! Gave me my life back. Can’t say enough good things about him.

Sep 17, 2026
Dr Peter Sculco is an excellent, kind, and caring Doctor who takes the time to thoroughly explain everything… He answers all questions without ever making u feel rushed…I would highly recommend him to family and friends!

Sep 16, 2026
Dr. Sculco did both of my total knee replacements three and five years ago successfully. I returned to have my right hip replaced and he used a Star method which has been exceedingly positive. Not only do I consider his knowledge, expertise, bedside manner and the staff he works with as stellar, the my mobility app that follows my post Surgery at this point is remarkable. I hold HSS and the doctors and medical staff in the highest degree.

Sep 14, 2026
He is very professional and hands on.

Sep 12, 2026
Exceptional,extremely passionate, professional, personal, easy to to talk and answer all questions

Sep 5, 2026
He was clear, informative, supportive and encouraging

Sep 3, 2026
Dr, Sculco explanations and answers to questions showed thorough knowledge and experience with my issues.

Sep 3, 2026
Overall experience excellent b staff were wonderful The physician was extremely knowledgeable about problem and explained things clearly n He asked for my input and I felt a part of the decision making process

Sep 3, 2026
Amazing experience. As a past HSS patient my expectations were high and they were exceeded by the staff and surgeon

Sep 2, 2026
Excellent caring through doctor

Aug 27, 2026
very impressed with the whole operation from xrays to consultation with Dr. Sculco.

Aug 27, 2026
The best Doctor ever .

Aug 27, 2026
Excellent results

Aug 25, 2026
Dr. Sculco and his staff always treat me with respect and kindness. Dr. Sculco has my upmost trust in him after doing all my 4 joint replacements over the last 4 years. He is knowledgeable, personable, and skilled in his profession.

Aug 25, 2026
I trust Dr Sculco 100%. Based on his reputation and based on my knee surgery last year and other people, I know that have used them as their Surgeon.

Aug 25, 2026
Dr. Sculco was amazing. easy to talk to, provided necessary information and was able to put me at ease.

Aug 21, 2026
Great experience overall

Aug 21, 2026
My doctor is an amazing doctor as well as a human; so kind, caring, concerned, better than my own brothers. So blessed he is in my life. Now only if my insurance would not give me headaches.

Aug 21, 2026
A positive experience from beginning to end

Aug 20, 2026
Extremely pleased with Dr. Sculco. Appreciate the time he took to explain everything to me & also got back to me right away when I had a question.

Aug 20, 2026
Dr. Sculco is very positive, reassuring and seems extremely caring about outcome. I have put my trust in him completely to achieve the results we discussed.

Aug 17, 2026
Excellent, kind and clear.

Aug 6, 2026
Dr Sculco-- excellent!

Aug 6, 2026
It was excellent. Dr Sculco was professional, thorough and answered all my questions.

Aug 6, 2026
Excellent

Aug 4, 2026
My experience at HSS was amazing. Dr. Sculco was very courteous and efficient, the staff was professional and the facility was immaculate.

Aug 3, 2026
You could add one or two more catagories of excellence to capture the quality of care with Dr. Sculco

Jul 30, 2026
Dr. Peter Sculco and his entire team are the best!

Jul 28, 2026
Everything went as scheduled as he said let me feel very comfortable as the first time I was ever in a hospital and I'm very pleased

Jul 20, 2026
Excellent explainer. Great positive energy.

Jul 17, 2026
Everyone involved in my visit was extremely polite and helpful from the moment I walked in the door. It is a pleasure to go for an appointment at the facility in Brooklyn. The free parking is greatly appreciated. I highly recommend HSS to all my friends and family members. I appreciate that the waiting time is minimal.

Jul 17, 2026
Dr Sculco is amazing!! There should be more people like him in the world!

Jul 16, 2026
All appointments at HSS are always the very best with the best office staff, PA’s and the best Doctors

Jul 16, 2026
Dr. Sculco is quite frankly the BEST DOCTOR I’ve ever seen at HSS. He is compassionate, caring, and has the absolute best bedside manner of any doctor I’ve ever dealt with. 5 stars all the way!!

Jul 15, 2026
This is my 4th replacement with Dr. Peter Sculco. He is a skilled surgeon who exhibits compassion and excellence in his field.

Jul 14, 2026
The procedure went well and the surgeon was very connected with the patient

Jul 13, 2026
Dr Sculco explained the procedure very well He gave me a good feeling and lots of confidence that the surgery would go well.

Jul 13, 2026
Excellent