Thomas D Magill , MD
Orthopedic Surgery
Franciscan Physician Network Monroe Health Center
400 Legacy Plaza West
La Porte, IN 46350 Directions
4.9 out of 5
149 verified ratings
149 Ratings, 78 Comments
The following ratings and reviews are based on verified feedback collected from independently administered patient experience surveys. The ratings and comments submitted by patients reflect their own views and opinions. Patient identities are withheld to ensure confidentiality and privacy.
Oct 1, 2025
Didn't recommend surgery. Starting with PT.
Sep 19, 2025
He took the time to explain everything going on with me and put me at ease.
Sep 17, 2025
Knowledgeable, friendly, explained things well
Sep 16, 2025
Same as above plus he took enough time for communicating.
Sep 16, 2025
Very nice man
Sep 15, 2025
I think he is a good surgeon and a caring doctor
Sep 10, 2025
Dr. Magill is the best. So thorough and patient. Explains things well and goes the extra mile. Lori, his assistant, is excellent and treats patients with special care.
Sep 5, 2025
Dr. Magill did a fantastic job and I'm progressing much faster than expected. He's very personable and answers all my questions.
Sep 5, 2025
He’s great and he listens to what I have to say……have already recommended him to my sister .
Aug 27, 2025
I love this doctor he knows what he's doing i tell my family and friends about him.
Aug 20, 2025
Dr Magill is very pleasant, and answered all my questions in terms I could understand.
Aug 18, 2025
Answers all questions, very friendly, compassionate. As is the staff.
Aug 14, 2025
He was very nice and knowledgeable.
Aug 13, 2025
He is a very caring and compassionate person. He makes the visits easy and reassuring.
Aug 12, 2025
Nice person and knowledgeable
Aug 11, 2025
He did root repair surgery on my meniscus a year ago in July. I healed nicely. He knows what he's doing and is an excellent and caring doctor.
Aug 9, 2025
3rd times a charm...2011, 2023, and now 2025....shoulder surgeries. Has always been good to me thru the years and definately refer him.
We laughed, said we need to work on another area...give my shoulders a brake! Haha
Aug 4, 2025
He is a very thorough physician.
Aug 4, 2025
He always explains what is going on and what solutions and options are available.
Jul 30, 2025
He's very kind and patient as well as thorough.
Jul 27, 2025
Attentive to his patients
Jul 26, 2025
Dr. Magill very personable and explained entire surgery and what to expect during recovery. Very patient with Mom understanding her dementia and level of understanding and repeated questions.
Jul 25, 2025
He is good, caring kind doctor
Jul 9, 2025
Very professional, personable, and knowledgeable.
Jul 8, 2025
He listens to his patients.
Jul 5, 2025
He was recommended to me
Jun 19, 2025
I trust him!!
Jun 8, 2025
He was wonderful and really explained everything to me
Jun 4, 2025
I love my surgeon however the pain from this surgery is alive and well and not controlled
Jun 3, 2025
Good Dr
May 30, 2025
Quality of work and understanding of the physical needs of the patient.
May 27, 2025
He answered all my questions and gave me a lot of information about my injury
May 24, 2025
Takes time to explain options and treatments.
May 20, 2025
He was super quick, blunt, helpful, and such a great listener. He listened to everything I had to say, gave me great feedback, and did his job very swiftly and to the point.
May 19, 2025
Only one that covered knees.
May 19, 2025
He was great
May 15, 2025
My husband recommended him and he's great
May 12, 2025
Great work and practise
May 8, 2025
Answered all questions and to the point.
May 6, 2025
He ask the right question and he was fast at getting to me before I finished the signature paperwork it went bam bam🤗
May 5, 2025
He is very informative on what he is going to do,towards the operation. Which I like. He is just a very great Dr.
May 1, 2025
Dr Magill, he actually listened to me and answered my questions…….don't find that much anymore, usually an in and out visit, a hi and goodbye but he actually took the time to make me feel that I had made the right choice in finding a new Orthopedic Doctor……
Thank you Dr. Magill !
Apr 30, 2025
Everyone at Emergency Room told me he is good and he has been easy to work with.
Apr 24, 2025
He did my left arm 2011, right arm 2023...now hurt my left again. I Trust in Dr. Magill full heartedly in helping me. Love his calmness.
Apr 22, 2025
He awesome
Apr 15, 2025
Gave me honest answers. Persanable
Apr 9, 2025
He is attentive and knowledgeable.
Apr 9, 2025
Awesome bed side manners
Apr 4, 2025
He was attentive and professional with me as a patient
Mar 31, 2025
Dr Magill is very knowledgeable and caring