Thomas D Magill , MD
Orthopedic Surgery
Franciscan Physician Network Monroe Health Center
400 Legacy Plaza West
La Porte, IN 46350 Directions
4.8 out of 5
138 verified ratings
138 Ratings, 68 Comments
The following ratings and reviews are based on verified feedback collected from independently administered patient experience surveys. The ratings and comments submitted by patients reflect their own views and opinions. Patient identities are withheld to ensure confidentiality and privacy.
Jan 16, 2025
Dr. Magill, has been my Ortho doctor since 2012 and I would follow him to whatever location he is practicing in. I have referred friends and family to Dr. Magill and they ALL have been very happy with the care he gives his patients.
Jan 15, 2025
He was understanding of my condition.
Jan 15, 2025
Dr. Magill has an excellent reputation and has been wonderful to explain things as I have had questions. I feel that he has my best interest, and he has been supportive, which means a lot.
Dec 11, 2024
Dr. Magill establishes a good rapport with the patient.
Dec 11, 2024
Dr. Magill and the whole team was very good to me. I highly recommend him they had some of the best attitudes I’ve ever seen good group of people thank you very much.
Dec 10, 2024
He is compassionate, knowledgeable, addressed concerns and answered all my questions. Dr. Magil has a reputation for being the best in his field. I trust his judgment and will follow his advice.
Dec 10, 2024
professionalism
Dec 10, 2024
Dr magill and staff were very nice and caring
Dec 6, 2024
See above. Dr. Magill took time to listen to me. And he explained my options. And gave me guidance. And Lori took over to schedule my needs. Plus the others in the office are so nice from reception to when I left.
Dec 3, 2024
Quick diagnosis and ordered test to determine treatment.
Dec 3, 2024
Dr Magill has been my doctor for over 25 years. He keeps putting me back together in all that time. Great doctor. He has all my trust and faith.
Nov 22, 2024
He has helped me before with knee issues & trust his opinion on with my shoulder
Nov 15, 2024
A very good doctor
Nov 11, 2024
He was personable and knowledgeable
Nov 7, 2024
Friendly and listens to concerns
Nov 5, 2024
Same as above also everything is done at the same office
Nov 1, 2024
I came for a second opinion, and I’m so glad I did! I was able to avoid an unnecessary CT scan. I felt like he cared about my health as opposed to how much money he could make. He also referred me to a Franciscan clinic much closer to home for my next appointment.
Oct 25, 2024
He's every nice
Oct 7, 2024
local
Oct 7, 2024
Great gentleman and doctor
Oct 6, 2024
Dr. Magill never rushes my appointments. He answers all of my questions and explains every procedure and concern thoroughly.
Oct 3, 2024
He explained my injury and recovery and was very professional and friendly 👏
Oct 3, 2024
Friendly and helpful
Sep 24, 2024
I've seen Dr. Magill of and on as needed for many years. I trust him
Sep 24, 2024
Dr. MaGill Truly cares about his patients and takes the time to explain your treatment.
Sep 21, 2024
He took time to explain what was going on and steps we would proceed towards getting me back to where I need to be.
Sep 18, 2024
Dr is too busy to provide timely treatment especially to elder patients
Sep 16, 2024
I’ve been to quite a few doctors have not ran into a group of workers in the office that are constantly smiling with good personality and most importantly good at their job it makes it easy for me to be a patient with them very grateful for that. Thank you very much.
Aug 27, 2024
He is very thoral with his exam. Nice person.
Aug 27, 2024
Seemed very personable and knowledgeable.
Aug 23, 2024
Communicates well
Aug 23, 2024
I was weary at first. I had a workman’s comp claim so I did not choose my own doctor but I couldn’t have asked for a better appointed doctor honestly. He was strait and to the point, seemed very confident it what he was talking about and answered my question’s completely. Him and his surgery team were very nice and helped me with my nervousness. No one wants surgery, but if I had to do it again I’d be happy to use Dr. Magill and his staff for any more Orthopedic needs.
Aug 22, 2024
GOOD DOCTOR
Aug 21, 2024
He is caring and explains everything
Aug 19, 2024
Quick response, very thorough.
Aug 14, 2024
knows what he is doing. After operation knee doing fine.
Aug 12, 2024
Dr. Magill is very professional and explained procedure to me. He also seems caring.
Aug 10, 2024
He was2 very personable. He was nice, but when I started to ask a question he says the nurse can answer those questions. I paid to talk to a doctor.
Aug 9, 2024
Pleasant ,explained steps and didn't feel rushed.
Jul 29, 2024
I think he’s a good surgeon but he never talked to my husband after my surgery. My follow up visit on July 24th was about 1 minute. I had questions for the doctor and he left the room before I had a chance to even ask anything. Thank goodness my recovery has gone well
Jul 26, 2024
Great doctor!
Jul 24, 2024
He takes his time with you, also looking into treatments.
Jul 22, 2024
Previous doctor several times
Jul 17, 2024
I didn’t know what to expect but I was impressed by the kind and professionalism of the team and the doctor!
Jul 13, 2024
Very knowledgeable and experienced. Trust his judgement and advice. Has helped me in the past!
Jul 11, 2024
1. I've known Dr. Tom for several years, from church.
2. Friendly, helpful staff.
3. Responsive to the patient.
Jul 9, 2024
He did my knee replacement and I trust his latest diagnosis
Jul 9, 2024
Nice doctor
Jul 7, 2024
Very kind knowledgeable.
Jul 5, 2024
He has repaired my arm before and don’t have any problems .He did an excellent job.