Mathew J Libke , MD

General Surgery

www.franciscanhealth.org

4.9 out of 5

101 verified ratings

101 Ratings, 62 Comments


The following ratings and reviews are based on verified feedback collected from independently administered patient experience surveys. The ratings and comments submitted by patients reflect their own views and opinions. Patient identities are withheld to ensure confidentiality and privacy.
Oct 23, 2025
He was direct and matter of fact with what needed to be diagnosed and accomplished for resolution of the matter. Very well-mannered, knowledgeable and I would highly recommend him.

Oct 22, 2025
Takes time to explain things. Friendly, caring

Oct 19, 2025
Surgery was explained. Recovery was explained. Great office staff . Beautiful smiles and friendly atmosphere. Surgery was successful

Oct 15, 2025
Doctor Libke was so easy to talk to. Explained the diagnosis and how to surgically correct the issue all the while being less invasive for a better outcome.

Oct 15, 2025
He took plenty of time with us!

Sep 29, 2025
Done a great job fixing an underlying problem we did not know about before the surgery.

Sep 25, 2025
Professional , friendly, and made me feel very confident about having him perform my upcoming surgery.

Sep 17, 2025
Dr. Libke was very personable and thoroughly explained my diagnosis and process of my pending surgery.

Sep 11, 2025
Exam and explanation of condition were thorough and concise. I like his no-nonsense yet kind personality.

Sep 8, 2025
Friendly, sized up problem, listened to needs and answered prayers

Sep 6, 2025
Friendly, answered all questions. Explained procedure.

Sep 3, 2025
VERY competent doctor, VERY pleasant, very knowledgeable

Aug 27, 2025
Skilled surgeon, kind, good bedside manner.

Aug 18, 2025
Well versed man.

Aug 13, 2025
Dr.Libke has been wonderful to me and trying to get me help through all the testing .making sure on everything medical is covered before doing surgery on me .all the drs he has he has put over my care has been great as well.absolutely would recommend Dr.Libke

Aug 13, 2025
Good job kind

Aug 8, 2025
He is the best

Aug 5, 2025
He explained everything to me in terms I can understand.

Aug 1, 2025
He listens to you and tells it like it is

Jul 28, 2025
Friendly, informative without hesitation and able to tell a joke to lighten up the situation at hand.

Jul 25, 2025
I had a very good appt. Dr Libke was very informative and very thorough. I appreciate the time he took with me.

Jul 18, 2025
The confidence he has in his information and feedback from listening makes you feel very confident and comfortable to have him doing your surgery. I was very impressed with him for a first time patient and truly understand why he was recommended.

Jul 16, 2025
Very successful surgery

Jul 16, 2025
Seems detailed and caring

Jul 9, 2025
He is a very good physician and has very good mannerisms.

Jun 23, 2025
He is a very knowledgeable professional.

Jun 20, 2025
Very nice and professional .

May 26, 2025
Very professional and patient focused.

May 21, 2025
Mannerisms

May 19, 2025
Great service

May 12, 2025
Dr. Libke did a wonderful job of correcting my obstruction and making it so my recovery has gone smoothly without any problems. Thank you Dr. Libke.

May 10, 2025
Very patient and explained everything in great DCO answered all my questions

Apr 21, 2025
Assured me it wasn't what I told could have been

Apr 18, 2025
He was very nice and while explaining everything in a serious matter he was easy to talk to and made me feel comfortable about the whole situation !!

Mar 29, 2025
Extremely professional and friendly.

Mar 29, 2025
Professional and direct. Down to earth

Mar 26, 2025
Dr Libke is absolutely a great doctor. Very professional and has great bedside manners. I’m so happy he’s my doctor!

Mar 26, 2025
He works with the patient to build the best plan of care. Explains everything in understandable terms. Outstanding surgical skills.

Mar 26, 2025
My first impression of Dr. Libke was a man with experience under his belt, And one who has knowledge of all understanding..

Mar 24, 2025
Very personable and knowledgable!!!

Mar 20, 2025
Very professional and to the point

Mar 16, 2025
Dr. Libke is a very professional doctor who does a very thorough examination before he gives an opinion. He also has an excellent bedside manner. Dr. Libke performed my gallbladder surgery five years ago and I was very pleased with how everything went. I trust him completely.

Mar 15, 2025
Knowledgeable, informative, and good communication

Mar 13, 2025
He was kind and explained the procedure to me and answered my questions

Mar 11, 2025
Love Dr Libke he is the best!

Feb 7, 2025
I've unfortunately have had a few surgeries, nobody is better than Dr. Libke. he is highly skilled , not an alarmist & honest. good doctors in Indianapolis are hard to find. he is a rarity in a city that lacks really EXCELLENT DOCTORS. Fortunately for me I got the luck of the draw. he addresses every question, he doesn't rush you and he truly CARES. KUDOS to Dr. Libke. not being from here, I have to say Franciscan Health is the BEST IN INDY. THE REST OF THE HOSPITALS PALE IN YOUR SHADOW. I have had some terrible doctor's especially at Eskashitty Hospital. mediocre at best IU Hospitals.

Feb 7, 2025
Very knowledgeable and patient oriented. Really like him.

Feb 6, 2025
He listened to me; asked appropriate questions. He did a thorough assessment, made a thoughtful diagnosis, and presented a reasonable plan of care. He is kind and an excellent communicator.

Feb 5, 2025
EXCELLENT!!!!!

Jan 29, 2025
for the same reasons as above. And when you study people you realize that when a persons smile reaches their eyes they are not just parroting words but they really care.