Judy Herbolsheimer, P.A.-C.
Obstetrics/Gynecology
25 E. M-55
Tawas City, MI 48763 Directions
4.9 out of 5
183 verified ratings
1 Location
183 Ratings, 107 Comments
The following ratings and reviews are based on verified feedback collected from independently administered patient experience surveys. The ratings and comments submitted by patients reflect their own views and opinions. Patient identities are withheld to ensure confidentiality and privacy.
AI Overview
Patients consistently praise Judy Herbolsheimer for compassionate, thorough, and professional care. She listens, explains medical information clearly, and makes patients feel comfortable during sensitive women’s health visits. Staff and clinic environment are repeatedly described as friendly, courteous, and efficient. Long-term continuity and high trust are common; many recommend her and the clinic highly. Few comments mention minor communication concerns, but overall sentiment is strongly positive.
Generated from the text of patient reviews
This AI summary is automatically generated from published patient reviews. It highlights common themes from the reviews, but as with all AI-generated content, there may be errors. Please exercise caution and refer to the original reviews for full context.
Oct 25, 2026
Judy and the staff were patient and kind to my elderly mother.
Oct 25, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
Judy was wonderful with my mom. Patient & kind.
Oct 21, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
Very thorough and attentive to my needs and allows me to participate in decisions about my care.
Oct 14, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
They are the best
Oct 9, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
All around good visit
Oct 7, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
Excellent
Oct 3, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
I asked if my low estrogen was the possible cause for the tendinitis I've been experiencing. Some of the ladies in my Threads social media group had mentioned it and I wanted to ask about that being a possible cause. I had an appointment scheduled with my PCP and spinal surgeon and was hoping for some insight. I got lectured about staying off of Tik Tok, which I've never used, She then went on a rant in the hallway with the staff about a [age], amlost [age] year old asking about estrogen. I never asked for replacements or to have my levels checked. I sincerely wanted to know if the menopause/low estrogen could be the cause of so much of the pain I'm enduring. I was mortified and so embarrassed. I cried the entire way home. It was horrible to be treated so badly.
Sep 30, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
Local doctor that treats you as. A person and not a number
Sep 25, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
I have always had excellent care from Judy. She and her staff are always helpful, compassionate and thorough with anything I have needed. Would highly recommend!
Sep 25, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
I stick w Judy and this office instead of switching to fl even though I life there most of the year bc she is so good. Also, my mammogram was done yesterday at 3pm and Judy’s office called by 10 am to tell me it was all good. That is amazing service!
Sep 23, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
I told them that my experience with Judy Herbolsheimer was horrible. I came in for a breast ultrasound referral. After palpating my the lump in my breast for less than 30 seconds, she proclaimed "Yep. That's cancer!" with a smile on her face. We briefly talked about where to see a breast surgeon, then she left the room so I could get dressed. I took me a few minutes to recover from her "diagnosis", and as I had more questions, I asked to see her again. I asked questions regarding the necessity and goal of a mammogram at this point. Her explanations included - I paraphrase - 'for the surgeon to be able to discuss the safest options with me, such as removing the lump or - and I quote - "Maybe you say 'I'm done with this (gestures nonchalantly down her front) - let's cut it all off'." I have never experienced such cold, uncompassionate care in my entire life! I have since removed myself from her care.
Sep 23, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
Judy H. Is very thorough, helpful and professional.
Sep 21, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
She is thorough, goes over all your family history with you, asks if you have any questions or concerns before she even does your exam.
Sep 18, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
Judy is attentive and smart and compassionate
Sep 17, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
I appreciate the way I am dealt with in that office
Sep 3, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
I'm so glad that I was given a referral to Judy. When I went into the office to make the appointment. They got me in right away. She made a very stressful appointment for me. Very relaxing and comfortable.
Aug 30, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
Caring provider!
Aug 26, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
That the PA was excellent and they should try the health clinic.
Aug 26, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
Friendly, profession, informative
Aug 25, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
Great office/staff
Aug 21, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
Excellent in every way
Aug 15, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
I loved her. She asked me lots of questions and listened to me and answered my questions. I was really impressed!
Aug 15, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
Very friendly and efficient, I think if you were to have a serious issue she would handle it quickly and would follow up with you!
Aug 14, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
They are the best
Aug 12, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
She's very easy to talk to and she listens with interest to concerns and questions.
Aug 7, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
I am very satisfied
Aug 3, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
They are very friendly and listen to what you have to say.
Aug 3, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
I like Judy, she’s always telling me what is going on with my health and she always answers my questions. I have no complaints.
Aug 3, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
Judy Herbolsheimer is an excellent provider that always takes the time to make sure I feel heard and understand everything.
Aug 3, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
Excellent care
Jul 23, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
I like her alot more than my actual dr
Jul 22, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
Judy is wonderful. She answers all my questions with compassion, knowledge, experience. Glad she is part of our healthcare.
Jul 17, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
It was my first visit in her office. Kindly Kindlyness started as soon as I entered the office! My nurse "Michelle" was amazing! Made me feel very comfortable and welcomed. When being seen for a very private issue she couldn't have done a better job and I thank her for that. Dr. Judy was exceptional with me ❤️ she left no stone unturned! I have been dealing with my issue since [YEAR] and these 2 ladies made me feel like things will be worked out. Thank you so very much! [NAME]
Jul 15, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
Very professional and thorough, highly recommended
Jul 13, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
Dr Judy was easy to talk to, professional and competent. I liked her very much.
Jul 11, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
I always have excellent services provided by Judy and this office
Jul 1, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
Amazing service and always comfortable.
Jun 14, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
Very friendly
Jun 13, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
That she is the best thank you
Jun 11, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
Got an appointment right away. Staff was very helpful and friendly
Jun 11, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
Very knowledgeable , friendly,
Jun 10, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
Nice people very friendly answered all questions.
Jun 8, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
I wouldn't go anywhere else for my care.
Jun 6, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
Judy is very social able, approachable and I felt very comfortable in her presence.
May 30, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
A great place!!!
May 28, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
It was good. Better than expected. I felt comfortable and felt like I could talk freely and honestly.
May 23, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
She is professional and very knowledgeable, caring and kind.
May 20, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
Judy and the rest of the staff at the clinic are always very friendly and professional. The receptionists always have a smile on their face and are always accommodating to each patients schedules when scheduling their next appointment. Judy takes her time explaining the procedures and is always willing to listen to your concerns. I have always felt safe and comfortable in her care as well as the nurses. They are all wonderful!
May 10, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
Judy is very compassionate about her patients and takes her time with them.
May 9, 2026
What would you tell family and friends about your experience with this provider?
Both PA and RN were great! Very thorough and knowledgeable.