Dr. James Gardner, MD
Family Medicine
315 E Elm St, Ste 200
Caldwell, ID 83605 Directions
4.9 out of 5
106 verified ratings
106 Ratings, 44 Comments
The following ratings and reviews are based on verified feedback collected from independently administered patient experience surveys. The ratings and comments submitted by patients reflect their own views and opinions. Patient identities are withheld to ensure confidentiality and privacy.
Aug 26, 2025
Dr Gardner makes you feel cared for and professionally treated. There is a sense of calm about him which is contagious. Comfort in a time of distress!
Aug 25, 2025
Helps the patient fully understand treatment options. He is willing to take what ever time required to fully communicate with his patients.
Aug 22, 2025
Keep him around!
Aug 21, 2025
I have had Dr. Gardner as my pcp for many years and am very sad that he will be retiring soon, but wish him the best.
Aug 21, 2025
Everyone in the Fruitland facility are very courteous and friendly.
Aug 20, 2025
Thank you, Dr. Gardner!!! You are super!
Aug 20, 2025
He was fine but he wasn’t my doctor and he wasn’t familiar with my history.
Aug 12, 2025
Need more old school doctors like this one.
Aug 11, 2025
He has been my doctor for ten years and I trust him.
Jul 25, 2025
Everyone who I came in contact with, reception, nurse who took vitals, and the doctor was polite and knowledgeable and very competent at their jobs.
Jul 14, 2025
Very appreciative of his care
Jul 11, 2025
Very personable and very professional.
Jul 11, 2025
Way above average in the care he provides.
Jul 11, 2025
Dr Gardner really knows his stuff, he explains things in ways I can understand. He expresses a very caring spirit, and is very straight forward and honest in responding to all my questions.
Jul 11, 2025
Excelled in every category
Jul 8, 2025
He took time to answer all of my questions.He seemed to genuinely care and made me feel comfortable which most doctors do not ..... Thank you Dr Gardner
Jul 2, 2025
would love to have him back as our primary doctor!!
Jun 30, 2025
See previous experience feedback
Jun 30, 2025
Good man.
Jun 4, 2025
Dr. Gardner was very clear on all explanations and seemed truly interested in looking out for all needs.
May 28, 2025
Bummed he is retiring
May 9, 2025
Dr Gardner is an asset to health care and to the St Alphonsus family in particular
May 9, 2025
Dr. Gardner is outstanding! Thank you!
May 9, 2025
All staff are great
May 9, 2025
seemed he was under time limits for patients compared to previous visits over the years
Apr 18, 2025
I will be very sorry when Dr. James Gardner retires, but happy for him.
Feb 27, 2025
Very good
Feb 27, 2025
Excellent care
Jan 16, 2025
Dr James Gardner is the best.
Jan 2, 2025
Dr Gardner is the best
Dec 19, 2024
I like the Doctor WHO listened and gave thoughtful feedback
Dec 19, 2024
He's the best
Dec 16, 2024
None at this time
Dec 9, 2024
Dr. Gardner was new to me. He was helping my Dr. who had surgery. Very friendly and asked lots of questions. Took all the time needed to review my issues. Relieved my worries about a medicine I need being refused by the pharmacy.Thank you!
Nov 22, 2024
I choose this facility because of the great care I receive.
Nov 15, 2024
Great experience
Nov 1, 2024
Very personable and professional
Oct 21, 2024
Has been family doctor for a lone time His care and experience has helped me through good and bad times hopefully he will be around for a long time
Oct 21, 2024
Doctor James Gardner has been my doctor for six years and I always have felt I was in the best of care.
Oct 18, 2024
Dr Garner
Oct 12, 2024
Dr. Gordon was just wonderful!!!
Oct 11, 2024
The best, no exceptions.
Sep 29, 2024
He has been my doctor for many years and through many health issues! I trust his judgement on my care in trying to keep me healthy but my body hasn't made it easy! Always has a positive attitude and a way of making me comfortable knowing he will be there to help me through any health issues I may have. Am grateful to have a kind, caring doctor who listens to and addresses my concerns!!
Sep 24, 2024
Dr. Gardner always listens to your health concerns. He is an excellent doctor