Alberto Carli, MD

Orthopedic Surgery

HSS - East River Professional Building

523 East 72nd Street, 7th Floor

New York, NY 10021 Directions

(212) 606-1445

www.hss.edu

4.9 out of 5

1,342 verified ratings

1,342 Ratings, 149 Comments


The following ratings and reviews are based on verified feedback collected from independently administered patient experience surveys. The ratings and comments submitted by patients reflect their own views and opinions. Patient identities are withheld to ensure confidentiality and privacy.
Oct 5, 2026
Professional, knowledgeable, friendly.

Oct 5, 2026
Provides constructive feedback

Sep 28, 2026
Love Dr Carli!! He is fabulous Dr and great patient interaction!

Sep 28, 2026
Dr. Carli and his entire staff are excellent to work with especially taking time to hear me, the patient, explain what I'm dealing with medically.

Sep 28, 2026
It was my first visit. But I feel confident .

Sep 24, 2026
Dr.Carli was excellent in all areas: sharing information and explaining his concerns. A true pleasure meeting him.

Sep 24, 2026
Dr. Carli was exceedingly nice and courteous. I appreciated his having me video record our visit.

Sep 21, 2026
Thank you

Sep 21, 2026
My experience with Dr Carli were beyond anything I could have hoped for. He went above and beyond—not only while I was in the hospital, but even after I returned home to recover. I never felt alone or forgotten. We don’t always experience this level of care, and I feel incredibly grateful to have been in such capable and caring hands every step of the way.

Sep 21, 2026
Dr. Carli was very knowledgeable and kind.

Sep 21, 2026
Dr. Carli was amazing! He’s very knowledgeable and really nice. I really like him. He had me video record everything he said, which was great, but I didn’t really have a chance to fully process all that he said, and only thought of questions after I left. I also thought I was getting a phone call in a couple days that I could ask for some PT recommendations but I never got that call. Maybe I misunderstood . I’ll send something thru the patient portal. By the way, your x-ray team is amazing. Absolutely no comparison to the University Radiology group I used. HHS truly is the best.

Sep 19, 2026
Was very attentive. He stopped in every day to check in and to give me an update

Sep 17, 2026
Dr.Carli had me turn on my phone and video him explaining my Xray and situation. It was genius. Not only was he thorough but I’ve been able to reference key points to refresh my recollection. We all know going to the doctors can cause anxiety and be stressful and not everything sinks in when there’s so much to grasp. I wish every doctor would suggest this.

Sep 17, 2026
It was a great experience -- Dr. Carli asked my son who was with me to video record the meeting a great first for me!

Sep 17, 2026
The doctor and PA were great Every detail was clear

Sep 16, 2026
Excellent care.

Sep 12, 2026
Dr. Carli was informative about the operation, scheduled all the tests and operation as close to my calendar as possible and always treated me with care and respect.

Sep 10, 2026
communication regarding all aspects of treatment was excellent

Sep 9, 2026
Dr Carli is kind and caring. He is an excellent surgeon with a great bedside manner.

Sep 3, 2026
Very pleasant and explains about the treatment clearly and understanding

Sep 3, 2026
They are good people very professional

Aug 31, 2026
Dr. Carli listened to all my concerns and addressed them carefully regarding my recovery and necessary steps to take for full healing. He gave me the pep talk I needed to keep going forward. Thank you Dr. Carli.

Aug 31, 2026
I cannot say enough about the care and perfection of the doctors and staff at HSS. As soon as you arrive you are greeted by a gentleman who directs you to check in. You are immediately assisted and taken for xraye or test in less than 5 minutes and promptly escorted to your doctor ‘s office. It is a well oiled machine. HSS is the hospital you want to care for your needs. They are best of the best are employed at HSS. Your doctor will provide you with all information and knowledge you need to know about your surgery, medication chronic pain and what to expect when you are discharged. They will provide outpatient care,nursing care, physical therapy. I am so happy I choose Dr Alberto Cali to perform my surgery. I tell all my friends and neighbors this is the hospital and doctor you need to handle your surgery. Thank you for your care and compassion and understanding.

Aug 29, 2026
I will be writing a personal letter of gratitude for the healthcare that I got my recent TKR!

Aug 28, 2026
Dr. Carli is both professional and personable. Most importantly, he is a fine surgeon.

Aug 28, 2026
Dr Carli is excellent. So much more thorough than any orthopedic I've ever been to. His knowledge is on another level. Highly impressed and thankful

Aug 27, 2026
In radiology I asked about getting images of both knees and was told I only needed one. Then I was sent back for a second xray. The radiologist should have checked.

Aug 26, 2026
Third surgery in less than 2 years. Skilled surgeon and strong communication skills when you meet with him

Aug 24, 2026
Dr Carli is kind, caring, smart and an excellent surgeon.

Aug 21, 2026
Dr Carli very knowledgeable, very kind and very caring. The X-ray staff also excellent. Actually brought me in for the x-rays 15 minutes earlier than my appointment. The young man that escorted me to the room was very helpful after finding out that the second type of x-ray had not been ordered and actually spoke to the doctor to get the x-ray order. This prevented the need for me to come back again for the needed x-ray. It was very much appreciated.

Aug 20, 2026
DR CARLI IS VERY THOROUGH AND KNOWLEDGEABLE.

Aug 19, 2026
Dr. Carli explained the procedure and kept my husband up to date during and after surgery.

Aug 17, 2026
Did not get to meet with the doctor the physicians assistance was OK not very helpful. I felt like I was hanging no questions answered.

Aug 13, 2026
Dr. Carli gave me my life back. Prior to my surgeries, I was basically a cripple and resigned myself to the fact that I’d have very little quality of life for the rest of my life. Dr. Carli gave back to me a quality of life I never dreamed as possible. The man and his team do God‘s work. What Dr. Carli achieved is just short of being a genuine miracle. I can’t say enough good things about Dr. Carli and his people. Thank you Dr. Carli for giving me my life back.

Aug 11, 2026
Dr Alberto Carli was immediately in contact when my emergency occurred. I was constantly updated on my care, my surgery date/time, what the next steps would be. He ALWAYS made time for any concerns/questions. He genuinely cares and has a passion for his field. Absolute incredible surgeon who goes above and beyond.

Jul 27, 2026
My wife had a bilateral knee replacement she had no problems and a quick recovery. For that reason I came here to see dr Carli for my knee issues

Jul 27, 2026
Dr. Carli is an amazing doctor - would highly recommend him to anyone needing a great orthopedic doctor.

Jul 23, 2026
Dr. Carli goes above & beyond to listen to any concerns I may have with my hip. I would highly recommend Dr. Carli to any family Member or friend who is having any issues eith a hip or a knee.

Jul 22, 2026
I was totally impressed with Dr Carli as he had a tough decision and truly put me, his patient, as the priority and realized he was not going to give my surgery 100 per cent

Jul 22, 2026
I cannot say enough about the care I received from Dr Carli and the hospital staff who were so kind and professional.

Jul 16, 2026
Excellent

Jul 11, 2026
I have already recommended Dr.Carli to 2 relatives. He and his staff are extremely attentive to the patients. He explains everything in detail. I have every confidence in him

Jul 11, 2026
Dr Carli is the best!

Jun 29, 2026
I was very impressed with the willingness of the doctor to allow me to record my visit so that I was able to share the information with my family,

Jun 29, 2026
Dr. Was extremely caring and pleasant.

Jun 25, 2026
planning surgury in 2027

Jun 20, 2026
This is a team effort

Jun 15, 2026
HSS STAFF, FACILITY, AND DR. CARLI ARE THE BEST!!

Jun 11, 2026
Dr Carli was excellent throughout the process explaining everything in detail and his videos. He came to the Recovery room and showed me an X-ray picture of what he had done and explained that the surgery went well

Jun 11, 2026
Great communication; very caring